The Great Debate: Choosing Between Metal and Plastic Nesting Boxes

With growing grocery prices and more and more people opting for farmsteads, there has been an increase in chicken coops or nesting boxes. Egg prices are skyrocketing; it has become cheaper to keep chickens. So, what are the best nesting boxes for chickens? Remember, chickens like to lay their eggs in quiet, dark places. Remember, chickens like to lay their eggs in quiet, dark places. If they don’t have a specific place to lay eggs, then they will just lay on the ground, which can lead to losses.

This video is sourced from Youtube@Nothin' But Gadgets

Ideally, young hens do a practice “laying” one week before they finally produce eggs. You should arrange for nesting boxes as soon as your hen reaches 15 weeks of age. Typically, backyard chickens prefer laying eggs in the same nesting box at least two or three times. So, when you are wondering how to choose chicken nesting boxes, the first item to check on the list is nesting box material. Here’s where you should start.

Table of Contents

• Why Material Matters
• Metal Nesting Boxes
• Top Metal Nesting Box Recommendations
• Why are Plastic Nesting Boxes Good? 
• How Do They Compare?
• How to Choose the Right Fit for Your Flock

Why Material Matters?

The end goal is ultimately your hens’ comfort and the production of good-quality eggs. The best nesting boxes or egg laying box setups affect the inner temperature and maintenance. It determines how warm or cold the box feels and how well it can resist moisture. Can it keep pests away from tiny cracks or seams? Quite a few backyard poultry blogs consistently highlight the importance of durable, dark and easy-accessible places for the hens. Cleanliness, of course, becomes the tipping point. People prefer a box that only requires fast bedding changes and simple scrubbing. That is why some prefer metal boxes with removable trays, while others prefer plastic boxes that can be washed with soap and water. The ultimate choice lies between long-term structural durability, or minimal labor based routine. The cost too influences that final decision.

Metal Nesting Boxes

The top contender for materials when it comes to chicken resting place, metal nesting boxes, are durable and spacious. It is a homesteader's dream unit. Bead bumps, scrapes, or the occasional roughhousing that comes with a busy poop, these boxes can withstand it all. To the question how long do metal nesting boxes last, the answer is decades. The answer is often "decades."

These heavy duty chicken nesting boxes resist damage and are better for hygiene. When climate changes cause the metal box to undergo temperature fluctuations, you can add a thick layer of pine shavings or straw. So, when perusing metal chicken nesting boxes for sale, remember you are investing long-term. You want to keep the eggs away from soiled bedding reduce accidental breakage, and make collection faster? Get durable roll away nesting boxes. 

Top Benefits of Metal Nesting Boxes

Without a doubt, the biggest selling point of heavy duty chicken nesting boxes is structural strength. Farmsteads are busy places with lots of activity. So, what do you need? A good galvanized steel model with minimal upkeep is a dream buy. Many reviewers have highlighted that multiple compartments mean dependable egg protection. Here’s why they are better.

• Does not rot or crack with heavy usage or under extreme weather conditions.
• Ideal for pest control.
• Easy to disinfect with a quick spray down.
• Stronger role system that reduces dirty or broken eggs.
• Redeeming features like angled floors, secure collection trays, perch bars, and vented side panels.
• Ensures cleaner and safer egg handling. 

Do Metal Boxes Help with Red Mites?

A frequent question asked by users is, “do metal nesting boxes prevent red mites?” Yes, they do. Naturally, it cannot eliminate mites by itself. In fact, sites like NestWatch emphasize that sanitation and pest management require a broader coop routine. That said, metal boxes offer a practical advantage. Since metal lacks porous cracks or crevices, pesky mites cannot hide and breed, benefiting your chickens' health.

Other poultry care guides suggest ways to treat cracks and seams when managing parasites. Get a sturdy metal box with removable parts, as it is more manageable. Essentially, it is a supportive hygiene tool when paired with removable nest pads or trays. You still have to change the bedding and treat the cook for mites.

What to Watch Out For?

Despite its various uses, here are some of the things to watch out for.

• The most obvious problem is temperature sensitivity. They heat up very fast in hot climates.
• If they are poorly ventilated, your chickens will be uncomfortable.
• A sturdy steel nesting box is often difficult to assemble and relocate.
• They might not be very convenient for a lightweight setup.
• They tend to be on the higher price side.

Top Metal Nesting Box Recommendations

When you search metal chicken nesting boxes for sale remember to check for features like roll-away collection, galvanized steel, easy-clean parts, and multi-compartment layouts. Here are some products that give you all of these and more. 

1. Nesting Boxes for Chickens, 6-Compartment Roll-Away Model

This copy model balances galvanized steel-frame, durability and easy maintenance. It has easy clean insert areas that are practical for anyone who wants a serious coup upgrade. It helps with an organised egg-laying routine.

Here are the features to look out for:

• Six laying areas for multi-hen use
• Auto egg collection system
• Removable trays
• Hanging holes for wall-mount or freestanding use.

2.  Duncan’s Poultry Standard Nest, 4 Hole

A popular brand, this nesting box is durable, extremely easy to install and clean. It is made of galvanized metal and is powder-coated by hand.

Here’s what you get:

• Dimensions: 28" wide 22" deep including perches and 36" tall.
• Capacity: Up to 40 hens
• Price at $139.99
• It is ventilated on both sides. 

Why are Plastic Nesting Boxes Good?

It’s a hot summer afternoon, and you’ve spent it just scraping dried nut or debris out of a coop. You begin to wonder, perhaps those plastic nesting boxes aren’t such a bad idea after all. And you’re right! When it comes to the easiest nesting box to clean you can blindly go for these. Are they nonporous? Yes. Are they easy to sanitize? Yes. Can they be bacteria or mold free? yes. These washable nesting boxes for chickens, save you time. If you live in coastal areas, then the salt in the air will rapidly corrode metal nesting boxes. Your other alternative is the rust proof chicken nesting boxes.

Do Plastic Nesting Boxes Have Any Benefits?

The answer is a resounding yes. Quite a few product reviews and blogs have effectively called plastic nesting boxes and easy to hose off, a simple to sanitize option. Imagine trying to clean broken eggs, manage. And constantly change the soiled bedding. Plastic is lightweight and non-rusting, so it reduces your effort by half. Here’s why you should go for plus. Plastic nesting boxes.

• Better for humid or wet conditions.
• It is the easiest nesting box to clean.
• Can we remove quickly and clean faster due to its lightweight?
• Just needs a soap and water wash down.
• Can be easily mounted and repositioned in any coop setup.
• It is warmer during the winter months.
• The smoothest offices discourage mite accumulation.

Where are the Limitations?

You want to find low-budget nesting solutions go for the plastic ones. However, they do have some setbacks. Here’s what you should be careful of.

• Low-quality models will wear down with sun exposure.
• They can become less stable and brittle over time.
• It is not suitable for a busy coop routine.
• It is not for owners who want a permanent installation.
• It is not a substantial material compared to metal.

Top Recommendations:

1. Deluxe Plastic Nesting Box

Convenient and stylish. This modular box is very easy to clean. The plastic keeps away mold, fungi and bacteria. Here are some top features. 

• Extremely durable.
• Can resist bumps and scratches on the surface.
• The hinged cover offers easy access to eggs.
• The bottom basket is closed, preventing the eggs from rolling away.

2. Garvee 8-Hole Plastic Nesting Boxes

If you are an experienced backyard chicken keeper, then you should opt for a larger nesting box. This nesting box with its 8-hole configuration is perfect for a larger flock. This keeps your chickens happy and maintains peace in the coop. Here are some standout features.

• Can resist moisture and mold growth.
• Good for exotic breeds of birds.
• Very easy installation and integration with the coop.

How Do They Compare?

You now know how each of these nesting boxes stands out. But stack them up side by side, and you will get a clearer picture. As a backyard, you can consider. Consider factors such as climate, time, maintenance, durability and usage before buying any of these. Which one serves you best?

Metal Boxes: If you have a bustling setup with lots of chickens and the physical stamina to clean and maintain your nesting box, then metal boxes are a good idea. Metal is heavier but can be rigidly mounted to almost any structure with minimal hardware. Not to forget the engineered roll-away systems that make egg collection easy.

Plastic Boxes: If hygiene is the top priority and the weather is extremely humid, then plastic boxes are a better choice. A beginner’s choice, plastic is much lighter to handle. You can do your seasonal deep clean by removing the boxes entirely.

This nesting box material comparison will give you some clarity.

How to Choose the Right Fit for Your Flock

Any experienced backyard chicken owner will tell you that choosing the right nesting boxes is not just about the material but also the setup. You have to consider things like size, space, location, nesting materials, cleaning habits, etc, but how far do you go? And what are the exact measurements? Here’s how you can create an inviting space for your hens.

1. Dimensions

Most owners go for standard breeds which can comfortably sit in a box measuring 12" x 12" x 12".It is just smart enough to keep the hands secure and retain body heat, yet large enough to prevent cramped feelings or accidental egg breakage.

• Large Breeds (Jersey Giants): May require 14" width.
• Bantam Breeds: They can easily fit in boxes measuring 10" x 10".

2. Strategic Location

Location should be the second priority. Choose the darkest, quietest corner of the coup and hence seek out secluded spots to avoid predators. Never keep the boxes in the entryway of the coop. Lower the roosting bass to discourage hens from sleeping in them at night

3. Height and Elevation

Elevate them off the grounds, ideally from 18 to 24 inches. This keeps away pests. The box is dry, and the birth is comfortable. You can install a landing perch or a 2-inch leg in front of the box so that your hand can inspect the area before hopping inside. 

4. Ratio of Boxes to Hens

Since Hens are communal, you’d not need to separate them into different boxes. You can give one nesting box large enough for three to four hens. Make sure they are not overcrowded, as this can lead to eggs being stepped on or them fighting over space.

5. Bedding and Cushioning

You can keep your nesting box clean and the eggs intact by using the right bedding materials. Use spine shavings as they are affordable and absorbent. You can also use straw or hay for excellent installation and nesting capability. Another great option is asper fiber pads, as they are easy to clean and hens can’t scratch them out of the box.

6. Privacy and Barriers

Since hens prefer closed, cave-like spaces, you can transform your nesting box into one. Add a front lip about 4 inches high to keep the bedding and eggs from rolling out. Cut up small burlap or fabric strips and use them as nesting box curtains to darken the interior. This will prevent the egg-eating habit by hiding eggs from view.

7. Accessibility for Cleaning

Before you build or buy, ensure that your boxes are easier to clean. This means adding removable bottoms or slanted roofs to prevent chickens from perching on the top. Create an external access to collect eggs without stepping into the chicken run.

8. Proper Ventilation

The final consideration should be ventilation. Your box should be cozy, but not airtight. If ammonia from nearby waste traps moisture, it is retained, and this could lead to respiratory issues. Make sure there is a small gap at the top or the sides of the box to allow passive air flow, without creating a direct draft

Ultimately, the best nesting boxes are those that are durable and suit your needs better. You live in a harsh climate. Prioritize long-term durability if you live in a harsh climate. Metal nesting boxes are your best bet, as long as you manage the temperature with adequate bedding. These permanent fixtures will save your flock for years. If your priority is easy cleaning, absolute rust maintenance and hygiene, then modern plastic nesting boxes are for you. Your chores become lighter, and your chickens live in a healthy, parasite-free environment with very little effort. The key here is to keep the box safe, dark and quiet irrespective of the material. This will increase the productivity of your flock. So now that you know all the features and the advantages, go take your pick from this premium collection of GARVEE nesting boxes.

More to read

How Many Nesting Boxes Per Chicken? Complete Guide for Backyard Chickens

Best Place For Nesting Boxes In A Chicken Coop